“Three strange beings … warbling”

The Fitz’s Stockton about a pioneer Stockton UFO brings this from reader Kevin Shawver:

“Did you know one of the earliest claims of attempted alien abduction was in an area between Lodi and Stockton? … The man who made the claim, H.G. Shaw, was the editor of the Stockton Evening Mail.”

He sends this remarkable archival stuff of the Mail story of Nov. 25, 1896.

Here’s Shaw describing the close encounter:

“They resembled humans in many respects, but still they were not like anything I had ever seen. They were nearly or quite seven feet high and very slender.  …  I asked where they were from. They seemed not to understand me, but began – well, “warbling” expresses it better than talking.

“… I noticed, further, that their hands were quite small and delicate, and that their fingers were without nails. Their feet, however, were nearly twice as long as those of an ordinary man, though they were narrow, and the toes were also long and slender. I noticed, too, that they were able to use their feet and toes much the same as a monkey; in fact, they appeared to have much better use of their feet than their hands.

“I presently discovered that this was probably a provision of nature. As one of then came close to me I reached out to touch him, and placing my hand under his elbow pressed gently upward, and lo and behold I lifted him from the ground with scarcely an effort. I should judge that the specific gravity of the creature was less than an ounce. It was then that I observed him try to grasp the earth with his toes to prevent my lifting him. You can readily understand that their slight weight made such a provision necessary, or they might be blown away.”

It goes on like that, wonderfully — unless you think newspaper editors, including retired ones, should not be fabulists. The best I can conjecture is that the Mail was trying to one-up the Stockton Daily Independent, which ran the stories about “the Stockton Airship” earlier in the year. Perhaps, in an era of three-newspaper towns, editors would do anything to win circulation wars. Or maybe such stories were done with a wink and a nod to the reader. Who knows?

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

#Stocktonhappy. For reals?

Seeing is believing. Visit Stockton has the video on its Facebook page.

And on YouTube:

Can’t keep this city down!

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

The BDCP: a failure of state institutions

Depending on the level of detail, the Bay Delta Conservation Plan and its twin tunnels adjunct can be dizzingly complex. In today’s SacBee, however, two enviros contribute a remarkably lucid Op-Ed piece.

“The proposed BDCP ignores the overwhelming scientific evidence that we must increase the amount of water flowing through the Delta to restore it to health, and instead focuses on siphoning away even more river water than the 50 percent on average we already divert,” write representatives from the Natural Resources Defense Council and Defenders of Wildlife.

“This approach would worsen the health of the Bay-Delta and California’s declining fish and wildlife. The state’s own analysis shows that the plan likely would lead to the extinction of several native salmon runs … Also, the BDCP is based on a risky and scientifically unproven assumption that man-made tidal marshes would compensate for taking more fresh water out of the Delta, an assumption that has been debunked by numerous independent scientific reviews …

“In its zeal to justify taking more and more water out of the Delta, the state Department of Water Resources – at the behest of several large water wholesalers in the San Joaquin Valley and Southern California – has lost sight of the bigger picture and ignored the need for long-term solutions that work within real fiscal and environmental limits, solutions that offer far better alternatives to improve California’s water future.”

There is the rotten core of the BDCP: a Department of Water Resources numb to its broader public responsibilities. Not to mention environmental reality, as faced by “the state’s own analysis.” How else to characterize a public water agency that could preside over the extinction of salmon runs?

The tragedy is this isn’t the “Cadillac Desert” era of the early 20th century. We know better. But if we follow the BDCP’s path, we’ll end up with the same destructive outcomes the dam-builders and river-killers achieved in their ecological ignorance.

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Denham: Impeachment? Maybe

Rep Jeff Denham, R-Turlock, refuses to rule out impeaching President Obama — for Benghazi, among other pretexts.

In a press release, The Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee quotes Denham speaking to the North Valley Tea Party Club in August 2013:

“If our Commander in Chief that was reelected in this country decides to break the Constitution it is a challenge to hold him accountable. And he’s done it several times now.”

“When asked if he would support impeachment, Denham said: “Impeachment is a, is a very serious issue. I think that you have to prove that the leader of the free world has done something that is so far against American beliefs that, and this trust that he’s been sworn into that you remove him. You know I think that him trying to move beyond these phony scandals is something that opens the door for us to investigate further. IRS targeting people, targeting individuals, targeting political organizations is a huge issue that we’re going to hold him account on. But the biggest issue for me thus far in this presidency has been Benghazi […]So depending on how far these investigations go we could get into a scenario where the president has broken the law.”

The Clinton impeachment is when the American political system broke down. He hadn’t done anything impeachable; Republicans, starting their journey into radicalism, just wanted him out of office. Same deal here.


Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

A galling reminder

The latest Calpensions article cites a 2013 report by the Pew Charitable Trust:

“In many states, the difficulties of major cities such as Stockton and San Bernardino would mobilize the state government to intervene and help them recover. But California offered no such aid, because it has long adhered to the belief that its cities should operate independently from the state.”

That’s a good one. The “independent” state eliminated redevelopment agencies and took any monies not obligated to address the state’s huge deficit. The independent state is bent on exporting Delta water for the benefit of other regions which in aggregate amount to state that cannot live without this region’s water.

I could go on. The point is the state and its cities are interdependent. Except when Stockton needs help. What a galling reminder that the state could and should help Stockton. If only we were rich megafarmers, living in Beverly Hills.

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

More Six States melarkey

Don’t dismiss the Six States proposal, writes MoBee Opinion Page Editor Mike Dunbar.

” … In a nutshell (choose almond or walnut), what have we got to lose?” Dunbar asks. “The rest of the state already ignores us.”

Our state will be an economic basket case — but it’ll have the water, Dunbar writes.

“As a separate state, we’d have the San Joaquin River and its delta mostly to ourselves. … Wonder how much some of that would be worth to folks in Beverly Hills or Tiburon or Menlo Park?”

If only. Water is not a regional property. It is owned based on a senority system: first come, first served, dating back to the 1800s. How the rights allocated within one California would play out if the crackbrained Six States proposal actually passed is anybody’s guess, because Vision Guy Tim Draper hasn’t addressed that little issue.
Presumably, rights holders would want their rights grandfathered in, or no deal. The Delta tunnels would probably go away; but presumably, also, big, “out-of-state” money would start flowing to our state’s politicians to help water exporters commandeer our state’s Department of Water Resources as they have done in the one California. Prohibiting that had better be our constitution’s Article I. 

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Chef’s fundraiser a success

Organizer John Britto says the July 21 Chefs Helping Chefs fundraiser for badly burned chef Richard Hyman raised $17,000.

A nice chunk of change.

“The community response was overwhelming,” Britto writes. “More than thirty businesses, organizations and associations bought tickets, donated cash, raffle baskets and silent auction items.

“Two hundred guests enjoyed culinary creations from two dozen chefs who came together from San Francisco, Manteca, Stockton, Lodi, Plymouth and Sacramento.

“Enjoying small plate tastings, supporters chose from a wide array of offerings including Spanish paella, poached salmon and grilled corn with micro greens, Carpaccio, shrimp sauté Diavolo, imported cheese selections, chocolate-ginger bark and assorted fruit Verrines. Cold hand-crafted beers and popular regional wines complimented the menu items.”

Britto showed real leadership in pulling this event together. The group he formed, Chefs Helping Chefs, will support other good causes.


Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

A message from Chief Jones

Police Chief Eric Jones leaves a message:

“I just wanted to say I appreciate the column you had regarding police tactics. As unfortate as it is, we really did follow just about anything out there regarding training in law enforcement. There are police experts we have been checking in with and they all —including the FBI, etc. — attest to the fact that, based on that situation, that was really standard training. As much as there could be.”

That is reassuring. Catching up with such experts should be part of the reportage in the incident’s traumatic aftermath. And, if the experts validate the SPD’s actions, part of the community healing.


Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Judge: High-Speed Rail can use Pacheco Pass

An appellate court judge, rebuffing the NIMBY cities of Atherton and Palo Alto, has cleared the way for high-speed rail to use the Pacheco Pass route between The Valley and the Bay Area. 

The Bay Area cities had challenged the rail’s Environmental Impact Report because those toffs don’t want a beastly train running through their Sunset Magazine showpieces.

After studying high-speed rail's proposed route, a south-Valley woman Photoshopped this image of the bullet train cutting in front of her house.

The local angle: had the NIMBYs won, high-speed rail would have had to change its alignment to the Altamont Pass. Stockton would probably have been moved to Phase I of the project, getting HSR years earlier than now scheduled. We could have whisked to the Bay Area on high-speed rail.

As it stands, Stockton is scheduled for Phase II of the project when the route is constructed up the Valley and through here to Sacramento, around 2020. But while HSR will traverse Stockton from north-state to south, it will not run from here across the Altamont. Instead, existing rail systems will be enhanced.

Either way, I believe the system will be a boon for Valley cities. If it survives court challenges, Republican opposition, local opposition, and the High-Speed rail Administration’s mistakes.

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Dissent of the day

Richard Edelstein writes:
“I take issue with your decision to focus the (bank robbery/hostage/chase) article on the defense of actions by police and whether or not the police acted professionally, competently and with integrity.  Of course we all want to believe and expect that the police made the right decisions and took the appropriate actions to deal with what was admittedly a tense, crisis situation with the life of a hostage and possibly others in balance.
“Your conclusion that the police acted correctly is simply premature.  There are no facts presented to the reader upon which one could reasonably draw the same conclusion you do.  Unless you have information not yet available to the public that provides sound evidence that the police acted properly and professionally, I see no reason you can credibly argue that the police hold no responsibility for the death of the hostage.  If you do have such information it should have been included in the article.  If there is an internal investigation, and I assume there is,  we should await its results before either defending or accusing the police in this matter.

Mourner Tammy Kidder at a vigil for Misty Holt-Singh.

“I have no reason to question the motives of the police or their professionalism and competency.  Nonetheless, due to the loss of a life of a member of our community, it seems especially important not to pre-judge what occurred in the press.
“To suggest that there may have been some mistakes or faults in judgement by the police should not necessarily suggest that they are culpable of gross incompetence or improper motives.  This was, as you note, an extraordinarily difficult and complicated situation for which an obvious solution or action was unlikely.  Still, it is reasonable to ask questions such as:  
“—Which decisions were the most critical to the outcome?  When did they occur?  Who made the decisions?  What were the criteria used? What were the alternative choices that were considered?  (These are tough questions that may be difficult to reconstruct given the rapidity of events, but they are necessary and reasonable questions.)
“—What is considered “best practice”  in a hostage taking crisis among experts and other professional police associations locally, in the state and nationally?
“—If “best practice” was not used in this case, why not?  What were the unique characteristics of this crime that may have made “best practice” impractical?
“—What lessons can be drawn from this experience that might result in a more effective response in some future event?
“Finding answers to these questions will not be easy and the results may be uncertain or limited.  Still, it is incumbent on all in our community to have the courage to ask these questions and seek answers.  If our police have integrity, professionalism and the desire to improve, they should also want to seek answers to these questions.
“We should give the police force the benefit of any doubts and not seek to create a politicized process when the focus must be on the facts and professionalism.  Your defense of the police was premature, not based on solid facts or information, and attempts to influence public opinion before the process of review and evaluation is complete.
“It was the right subject, but not the right opinion or content at this time.”
I take Edelstein’s points. But news is new. Readers subscribe for the paper’s mixture of immediacy and perspective on events. The answers Edelstein seeks will be months in coming. Preliminary judgements are necessary, given they are clearly preliminary.
I did, for the record, contact a national police organization to ask what options the police might have had to a rolling shootout. They did not respond. That was a disappointing hole in the column. But that’s deadine journalism.
Also for the record: Far from me being some complacent defender of police, my ignorance of all I should know in a novel tragedy such as this gnaws at me night and day. Edelstein is right that we must seek better understanding. That is why I left the posibility open that, as facts emerge and our understanding deepens, our judgment of the police’s actions may have to be revised.
My methods and judgments are as open to scrutiny as the police’s. Comments such as Edelstein’s help keep those methods smarter and more ethical than I could ever be alone.  

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment
  • Blog Authors

    Michael Fitzgerald

    Mike Fitzgerald is The Record’s award-winning metro columnist. His column runs in the paper three times a week. Born in San Francisco, he was raised in Stockton. His column covers diverse beats including, sometimes, the offbeat. Read Full
  • Categories

  • Archives

  • RSS Related Content

    • 'Flying machine' wowed Stockton, vexed press in 1896
      The mysterious flying craft was made of metal. It stretched around 150 feet, sported two flapping canvas wings and sprouted a rudder shaped like a bird's tail. […]
    • Hell on wheels? Sure, why not?
      Crossing India is an adventure. Crossing India during monsoon season is a punishing adventure. Crossing India during monsoon season in a flimsy motorized rickshaw ... are you kidding? […]
    • Nocetis' conviction on festival admirable
      Kudos to promoters Tony and Carol Noceti for their bold pledge to revive the Asparagus Festival. I wonder if they realize what they are getting into. […]